Child Participation Case Study

Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) hears the views of children and young people during inspections of children’s services

How the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) hears the views of children and young people during inspections of children’s residential centres, foster care and child protection and welfare services, detention and special care units.

Background Information

The Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) meet with children and young people during inspections of children’s residential centres, foster care and child protection and welfare services, detention and special care units. HIQA consults children and young people as part of its everyday practice on inspection. Although this is routine practice, over the course of the COVID-19 restrictions, there have been some changes to our routine practices. In May 2020, during COVID-19 restrictions, we contacted children in statutory residential care and special care by phone over a two-week period in May 2020 to ask children to describe their experience of COVID-19 restrictions and the services they were receiving during this time.  We conducted an art competition for children and young people in statutory residential care and secure care (including special care and detention) where we asked children to tell us about how they were being creative or had shown or experienced a kindness during the COVID-19 pandemic.

 

Since 2020, while we have had some face-to-face contact with children and young people, we also have contacted them through telephone, video-calls and sought their views by questionnaire.

 

Individual HIQA inspectors are responsible for listening to the views of children or young people in the care settings where they live or in child protection services in the community. Other inspectors may also meet with and interact with children and young people during inspections. Inspection methodologies for residential, detention, special care, foster care and child protection inspections have a built-in component for participation and consultation with children and young people who have experienced these services. This happens through questionnaires, face-to-face contact, phone contact and contact via other electronic mechanisms such as video calls. When we have face-to-face contact with children and young people, we use some of the Hub na nÓg [1] methods such as cloud tools, body maps, table mat activities and templates to draw on using pens and markers.

The decision-makers who are responsible for acting on the views of children or young people are HIQA inspectors and staff and managers from inspected services.

HIQA inspectors meet and consult with children and young people from the age of six to obtain their views about the service being provided to them.

The children and young people we meet and consult with are from a variety of backgrounds. Given the role of HIQA regarding inspecting social service provision, children and young people have often experienced adversity in some shape or form. This could include child abuse or neglect, social disadvantage, parental substance abuse or domestic violence.

[1] Hub na nÓg is a national centre of excellence on children and young people’s participation in decision-making

How we gave space, voice, audience and influence to young people’s views

Space

pace

Things we considered What we did
How we make sure that children and young people feel safe to express their views
  • We have had mixed experiences of using online settings as some children have been reluctant to speak using video calls –whereas others are very comfortable with it.
  • In both an online setting and face-to-face settings, we initially explain to children what our role is and how the information they share will be used. At the outset, children are advised if concerns for their well-being/safety come up, we will have to share information with their Social Worker.
  • Children are given the opportunity to ask questions before we start our direct work with them.
How we allow enough time to listen to and hear their views
  • This is part of our methodology and using time to engage with children and young people to listen to their views is a central part of our inspections.
How we make sure that all children or young people are heard
  • Children and young people choose the location within the premises or if they would prefer phone/other electronic contact.

Voice

oice

Things we considered What we did
How we support children and young people to give their views and be heard
  • Children and young people choose the location within the premises or if they would prefer phone/other electronic contact.
How they can raise things that matter to them
  • Inspectors let children and young people know that we want to hear about their views and experiences of the service.
  • We ensure they feel heard by always asking near the end of the conversation if there was anything else they would like to share.
  • We also go through what we have recorded/or what they have drawn/written – so that we are all clear on their views.
How we offer them different ways of giving their views
  • Various tools are used such as conversation, questionnaires, focus groups, body maps, clouds tool and art and crafts, depending on what best meets the child’s needs and preferences.

Audience

udience

Things we considered What we did
How we show children and young people that you are ready and willing to listen to views
  • We meet them at the pre-arranged time and let them know how important it is for me to listen to their views about things which impact them.
  • If children or young people raise any issues, the inspector clarifies with them if they would like the inspector to take any actions on their behalf (for example, individual children have raised that they wanted their social worker to visit more and they gave consent for this information to be shared with their social worker).
How we make sure that they understand what you can do with their views
  • We advise children and young people at the start of conversations as well as repeating at the end when thanking them for sharing their views with me.

Influence

nfluence

Things we considered What we did
How they know the level of influence they can have
  • We explain to children and young people that their views and experiences are included in all of our inspection reports, which not only are provided to the service we are inspecting but are published.
How we give them feedback
  • We send thank you cards to children and young people when possible.
  • Many services share published reports with children and young people.
How you share with them the impact of their views on decisions
  • In addition to individual inspection reports that highlight the views of children using services, an overview report on the inspection and monitoring of children’s services is published on an annual basis.
  • The overview report presents the collective views of children as well as the individual voices of children and comments on overall improvements in services.
  • Last year HIQA used social media through child friendly infographics and videos to provide information on general findings, as well as children’s experiences of services.
How we explain the reasons for decisions taken
  • We explain our role and remit when we begin conversations with children and young people, so they are clear about what we do.
  • They are aware that their views and experiences are included in our inspection reports.

Impact

The changes that have been made because of children and young people giving their views

Inspections impact the services provided to children, young people and their families. As obtaining children’s and young people’s views are a crucial part of our inspections, their views are heard by the service as well as the public. Over the course of our inspections, some children have spoken to us about how they contribute to their own plan of care. While other children have told us that they are involved in ‘children’s groups’ or attend children’s meetings which have influenced how the service provides information to children and is operated.  For example, on one inspection, children were involved in developing an information booklet for children in care.

Children’s and young people’s views are also taken into consideration when we in HIQA are developing our processes relating to how we engage with children. For example, in 2021 our team developed new children’s questionnaires and piloted these with children. We received feedback from children about the language and format of the questionnaires. As a result of their feedback, some changes were made to the questionnaires to make them more children/young person friendly. We also used different questionnaires depending

The learning for our organisation

Help protect children
UNICEF | for every child

Stay Informed and Make a Difference

Add value to your inbox with inspiring updates on UNICEF's impactful work for children.

By signing up today you'll receive exclusive insights into the incredible difference you can make, programme updates, emergency appeals and unique opportunities to get involved.

Keep up-to-date on what's going on around the world. Sign up today!

You can update your communication preferences at any time. For further information please see our privacy policy.

Website Developed by FUSIO